Date: Wed, 24 Sep 2014 17:03:19 +0200
From: Florian Weimer <fw@...eb.enyo.de>
To: oss-security@...ts.openwall.com
Subject: Re: CVE-2014-6271: remote code execution through bash

* Florian Weimer:

> Chet Ramey, the GNU bash upstream maintainer, will soon release
> official upstream patches.

http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-3.0-patches/bash30-017
http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-3.1-patches/bash31-018
http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-3.2-patches/bash32-052
http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-4.0-patches/bash40-039
http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-4.1-patches/bash41-012
http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-4.2-patches/bash42-048
http://ftp.gnu.org/pub/gnu/bash/bash-4.3-patches/bash43-025

Someone has posted large parts of the prenotification as a news
article, so in the interest of full disclosure, here is what we wrote
to the non-vendors (vendors also received patches):

Debian and other GNU/Linux vendors plan to disclose a critical,
remotely exploitable security vulnerability in bash this week, related
to the processing of environment variables.  Stephane Chazelas
discovered it, and CVE-2014-6271 has been assigned to it.

The issue is currently under embargo (not public), and you receive
this message as a courtesy notification because we assume that you
have network-based filtering capabilities, so that you can work on
ways to protect a significant number of customers.  However, you
should not yet distribute IPS/IDS signatures, publicly or to
customers.

At present, public disclosure is scheduled for Wednesday, 2014-09-24
14:00 UTC.  We do not expect the schedule to change, but we may be
forced to revise it.


The technical details of the vulnerability follow.

Bash supports exporting not just shell variables, but also shell
functions to other bash instances, via the process environment to
(indirect) child processes.  Current bash versions use an environment
variable named by the function name, and a function definition
starting with 鈥�() {鈥� in the variable value to propagate function
definitions through the environment.  The vulnerability occurs because
bash does not stop after processing the function definition; it
continues to parse and execute shell commands following the function
definition.  For example, an environment variable setting of

  VAR=() { ignored; }; /bin/id

will execute /bin/id when the environment is imported into the bash
process.  (The process is in a slightly undefined state at this point.
The PATH variable may not have been set up yet, and bash could crash
after executing /bin/id, but the damage has already happened at this
point.)

The fact that an environment variable with an arbitrary name can be
used as a carrier for a malicious function definition containing
trailing commands makes this vulnerability particularly severe; it
enables network-based exploitation.



So far, HTTP requests to CGI scripts have been identified as the major
attack vector.

A typical HTTP request looks like this:

GET /path?query-param-name=query-param-value HTTP/1.1
Host: www.example.com
Custom: custom-header-value

The CGI specification maps all parts to environment variables.  With
Apache httpd, the magic string 鈥�() {鈥� can appear in these places:

* Host (鈥渨ww.example.com鈥�, as REMOTE_HOST)
* Header value (鈥渃ustom-header-value鈥�, as HTTP_CUSTOM in this example)
* Server protocol (鈥淗TTP/1.1鈥�, as SERVER_PROTOCOL)

The user name embedded in an Authorization header could be a vector as
well, but the corresponding REMOTE_USER variable is only set if the
user name corresponds to a known account according to the
authentication configuration, and a configuration which accepts the
magic string appears somewhat unlikely.

In addition, with other CGI implementations, the request method
(鈥淕ET鈥�), path (鈥�/path鈥�) and query string
(鈥渜uery-param-name=query-param-value鈥�) may be vectors, and it is
conceivable for 鈥渜uery-param-value鈥� as well, and perhaps even
鈥渜uery-param-name鈥�.

The other vector is OpenSSH, either through AcceptEnv variables, TERM
or SSH_ORIGINAL_COMMAND.

Other vectors involving different environment variable set by
additional programs are expected.



Again, please do not disclose this issue to customers or the general
public until the embargo has expired.